8 Special Celebration Foods | The New England Holiday Bucket List

Savor the flavors of the New England holiday season with signature foods from both near and far. Here are eight popular eats, and where to find them.

By Yankee Editors

Oct 28 2021


Gingerbread Houses

Photo Credit : Illustration by Julia Emiliani
TRAVEL NOTE: Covid-19 concerns may affect operations this holiday season and beyond. Before making your travel plans, please check the latest visitors’ information for individual businesses and attractions by going to their websites or contacting them directly.
Delicious and special things to eat are often some of the best parts of the holiday season. Enjoyed alone, with friends, or at a large family gathering, these festive foods are beloved seasonal treats.
8 Special New England Holiday Foods
Photo Credit : Illustrations by Julia Emiliani

8 Special New England Holiday Foods…And Where to Find Them!

Feast of the Seven Fishes

For many Italian-Americans, it wouldn’t be Christmas Eve without an epic seafood feast of salt cod, shrimp, squid, clams, mussels, and other oceanic delicacies. In Italy, it’s common for Catholics to eschew meat the night before Christmas, but the tradition of serving seven seafood species is considered an Italian-American creation (the number seven signifying the number of Catholic sacraments, the days of creation, and the seven virtues and deadly sins). Many Italian restaurants serve these feasts around Christmas, and this year Mare Oyster Bar in Boston’s North End will offer fish such as branzino, salmon, oysters, and calamari over six prix fixe courses on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. 

Gingerbread Houses

The gingerbread house tradition began in 19th-century Germany, after which immigrants brought the lebkuchenhaus to America. Take in the wonder of modern-day cookie constructions at the Gingerbread House Festival at Wood Memorial Library in South Windsor, Connecticut (11/26–12/19), where gingerbread houses range from professional-grade village-scapes to little graham cracker cottages stuck together with oozy icing by festive 5-year-olds. 

Candy Canes

Drugstore candy canes are fine, but hand-pulled confections from such makers as New Hampshire’s Nelson’s Candy and Musicand Vermont’s Laughing Moon Chocolateselevate this everyday sweet into a giftable creation. The hard candy mixture is folded, pulled, layered, and twisted, resulting in translucent layers of red and white that gleam like stained glass windows and taste as fresh as a December morning.


The seasonal arrival of eggnog in stores puts Bing Crosby on a happy loop in our heads. You can go commercial (Hoodmakes several tasty variations, including pumpkin spice); small-batch (we’re partial to Connecticut’s Arethusa Farm); or even homemade eggnog. Just be sure to drink up!

Christmas Cookie

In 1969, Mary Bevilacqua and Laurel Gabel of Wellesley, Massachusetts, gathered a small group of friends in a living room to exchange cookies potluck-style. Today, three generations of Mary’s family share duties in hosting the famous Wellesley Cookie Exchange, which has spawned several Yankee articles and a cookbook. In turn, countless others have adopted the tradition for themselves. Bake up some of Yankee’s favorite Christmas cookie recipes (including some original Wellesley favorites) this holiday season.


Many Latin American and Caribbean cultures serve variations on Christmas pasteles, which are similar to tamales, but filled with different ingredients and wrapped in banana leaves rather than corn husks. And since about five percent of New Englanders have Puerto Rican ancestry, the region is rich in restaurants that make this delicious and time-intensive holiday staple. At Mana Escondido Café in Boston’s South End, owner Angel Carrasquillo makes pasteles from late October into early January. Fillings range from pork and chicken to vegetarian options. “People just love them,” he says. “If I didn’t have them, they’d be upset.” 

Christmas Pudding

Even if British-style puddings aren’t in your repertoire, you may remember the scene in A Christmas Carol when Mrs. Cratchit enters “flushed, but smiling proudly,” bearing a plum pudding “like a speckled cannonball” blazing with ignited brandy and crowned with Christmas holly. It takes a lot of work to get this holiday delicacy right—luckily, The English Cousinsof Middletown, Rhode Island, will do all the requisite soaking and steaming for you. Based on a 1910 family recipe, their puddings are loaded with fruit, molasses, and butter; soaked in rum; and coated in icing. Better yet: They deliver. 


Eating foods fried in oil—specifically the thin, crispy pancakes known as latkes—has long been central to the Jewish holiday of Hanukkah. But it wasn’t until potatoes made their way from South America to Europe a few hundred years ago that the form met its apotheosis. We love the latkes served at Mamaleh’s Deliin Cambridge and Brookline, Massachusetts, and at Rose Foodsin Portland, Maine. Or you can make your own homemade latkes.

See More: 6 Can’t-Miss Christmas Celebrations